Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image

PrettyQueer.com | January 26, 2015

Scroll to top

Top

72 Comments

Canon Fodder, or Screw You And The Top 10 List You Rode In On

Canon Fodder, or Screw You And The Top 10 List You Rode In On
Tom Léger

The creation of a list is the creation of boundaries in a way that is necessarily normative and anti-queer.

When I was an undergraduate English student, the field was going through an anticanon phase and the way that this played out for students was thusly: at no time during my studies was I ever expected to read, write or know anything about the play “Hamlet,” but I was asked to read, and was tested on Shakespeare’s lesser-loved work, “Cymbaline.” I will leave it to scholars much more intelligent than me to discuss the relative literary merits of the two works, but the intention was to improve the education of the students by expanding our literary horizons to works we would have been unlikely to encounter previously, or ever again. However, this attempt was seriously flawed in that while it made the professors feel that they had caused a great shift in perspective, in fact it only proved to reascribe Mr. Shakespeare’s work at the center of the English-language literary tradition.

These cycles and pitfalls of canon/anticanon play out in any number of media arenas, from art galleries to The Huffington Post, and queer media is far from immune to the dangers of reifying the normative through attempts to counter it. Nowhere is this effect more insidious than the “Top 10″ list format published by nearly every queer media outlet, most recently in today’s Autostraddle Hot 100 2012: The Hottest Queerest Women In All The Land. It is not enough to point out that this list fails to include an appropriate number of trans women, of women of color, of women above a size 16, of poor women, of disabled women. Autostraddle’s use of the word “Hot” instead of “powerful” such as Out or “under 40″ like the Advocate is a false indication that it is able to subvert the paradigm by simply redefining the word hot to include various kinds of hotness. The problem with these list formats is that there can never been a list that is properly inclusive, because the form itself is necessarily exclusive. It would be politically impractical or even impossible to create a list like this that is truly inclusive, not because of the debate around who should judge such hotness but the idea that one person or group can judge the hotness of all queer women and elect a top 100, or top 1000, or top 10,000 for that matter. The creation of a list is the creation of boundaries in a way that is necessarily normative and anti-queer.

In realities these types of lists are created as much out of cheapness of production and the “viral marketing” value of the article. In this way, growth of the list from 10 to 100 Hot Queer Women is done as much for marketing purposes as it is the facade of inclusion. Instead of 10 people, there are 100 people sharing the article with their friends, who share it with their friends, etc. (This reminds me of an old East Village theater adage attributed to playwright Madeline Olnek, “If you want your play to be a hit, get a big cast and put the word ‘lesbian’ in the title,” which proved true time and time again.)

Maybe this seems silly, to be so concerned about a list of 100 Hot Queer Women, and it is, or rather it would be if it were limited only to these silly lists. In reality, the echoes of this type of content curation are seen over and over again in queer media: as boundaries are constructed, the content gets worse and the editorial process itself destroys the genre. Sarah Schulman has described the process of starting out as a lesbian novelist published by mainstream presses and watching as bookstores such as Barnes & Noble erected Gay & Lesbian sections, relegating to it her books and many books by other lesbian authors. In recent years, large publishers are more resistant than ever to publish work with lesbian content, as it is immediately segregated into the Gay & Lesbian section of The Bookstore and almost immediately forgotten.

There are many many ways we as writers and editors can address and overcome this, but be sure that the stakes can not be overstated. To leave, for a moment, the queer blog arena, I offer this thought experiment: Imagine that the head librarian at the New York Public Library has a red telephone that connects directly to the Oval Office, and in case of global thermonuclear war, that librarian gets a call. And at that time, the librarian needs to go into a bunker to wait out the disaster of all humankind and can only bring along the books that he or she can carry by hand, so maybe up to 30-40 books (if this is an especially robust librarian). Which books should the librarian choose? The Riverside Shakespeare? the OED? What about non-English books? How many books by women or by people who aren’t white? How many books by trans women of color?

I am encouraging my fellow content curators to diversify their portfolios.

The librarian’s task is almost impossible, but consider that while the NYPL houses about 45 million items, while the internet houses almost 200 million blogs alone. Our head librarian could spend his or her life’s career curating their doomsday list, while, as blog editors, we have to make these decisions constantly. True, the stakes may not be as high as global thermonuclear war, but in the arenas of queer media, curators have nearly as much influence over the future of culture as the librarian selecting the few dozen books that the next generation will get to read. Wouldn’t it serve us better to not build barriers where none existed before?

Even without the list-making, of course all content curation is necessarily the difficult process of selecting some content and excluding the rest. It is the job of curators to make decisions, as wisely as possible, about collecting and disseminating content, and the duty of consumers of the artifacts to judge and consume in as wide a range as possible. The process will always been necessarily flawed and beyond my suggestion to avoid the superficial list-making so popular in media from Autostraddle to the New York Times, I have only one other suggestion to ponder.

In the world of finance, even a first-year junior analyst understands this basic tenant of portfolio theory: there is almost no reason to ever pick individual stocks. Because of a fairly boring mathematical equation that I will spare you at this time, we know that pretty much any diversified portfolio of stocks will go up and down pretty much in line with an overall market index, like the S&P 500. The amazing thing about this theory is that a portfolio of even 10 or 12 stocks, selected completely at random, is going to act almost exactly like the market as a whole. This is the major reasons mutual funds exist, because this level of diversification is so desirable to investors. “Stock-picking” or the process of sitting down and analyzing individual company’s stocks in order to try to pick stocks that will “beat the market” almost always backfires, in fact. It is understood that some of the stocks in the portfolio will go down, and some will go up, but on average, it will probably look a lot like the returns of the market as a whole.

Analysts who consistently beat the market returns are almost always able to do so because of insider trading or outright fraud. Bernie Madoff’s fund was so popular because he appeared to be able to, against all odds, beat market returns through stock-picking. He’s currently on year 2 of a 150-year sentence in Butner Federal Correction Complex after having defrauded and destroyed the personal wealth of thousands of investors. Stock-picking doesn’t work.

What if our head librarian at the NYPL, instead of laboriously picking the 30 or 40 most important books ever printed using whatever method, knowing, after a long career as a book curator and researcher, that there is no way for him or her as an individual to actually select the most important 30 or 40 books to all of humanity. What if they instead selected 30 or 40 books completely at random? The librarian would have to assume that some of the books would be garbage, and some of the books would be spectacular, but overall they would average out to a realistic collection of written culture as it was in 2012. What a different list that would be.

I am not advocating that editors curate content the way that brokers select stocks for mutual funds anymore than I would recommend that an author randomly spew words on to a page in an effort to create, on average, the best book possible with those words. Instead, I am encouraging my fellow content curators to diversify their portfolios. I am certain that the process of actively seeking out subjects and authors who are foreign to you, who define themselves in language that is unfamiliar and whose narratives are unlike those you are already publishing will improve your product. Resist building boundaries around them with definitions and containers that will necessarily prove false just to increase short-term readership.

I hope that we can come to understand that it is impossible to pick the actual best or the actual hottest or the actually most powerful queer people. It is as useless and dangerous as the process of picking individual stocks, or trying to beat the returns on the market against all odds and mathematical laws. Ten years on, I have no recollection of Cymbaline’s characters, plot, or when it was written in relationship to Shakespeare’s other works. As an editor I struggle with the same challenges that all curators do, how to simultaneously serve my readers, my authors, and my ego. Let this essay be not read as a criticism of my peers as much as it is an admission of personal guilt and awareness of immense responsibility, as in writing it, I wish only to avoid hoisting myself on my own petard.

Comments

  1. Hey Tom I can tell you who the coolest character in Cymbeline was, if you want to know.

  2. “The creation of a list is the creation of boundaries in a way that is necessarily normative and anti-queer.”

    I so agree with this statement of yours. It never ceases to amaze me that, for all the supposed liberation the queer movement tries to claim for itself, it mostly includes very narrow archetypes of what is queer and what isn’t… not to mention who’s hot and who isn’t. Same old Sh*t in a new package. :(

  3. Truth!

    I’m a big infogeek, and I love curating content. What you’re describing constantly annoys me, and these days I’m trying to do a lot of curation that doesn’t have these problems. I’ve found Pinterest to be really useful both for curating boards of content that’s all POC-related, disability related, trans related, etc. and for curating boards that are general on a theme and include an actual diverse selection of images.

  4. Katie Liederman

    Tom this is so good.

  5. start a school tshirt in book rosacea treatments todds truth calvin klein [url=http://www.discountmcmjapan2013.com/]MCM 通販[/url]
    [url=http://www.discountmcmjapan2013.com/]MCM 激安[/url]
    sai gon map pit pony express english indonesian crx230ee plextor convertx bunn grinders My little pony Fun games open file manager [url=http://www.monsterheadsetsjp.com/]モンスタービート ヘッドフォン[/url]
    x m radios dip 8 fingerprint kits serengeti drivers powakaddy classic camera cannon sewing drapes disney pin

  6. to work Like all identification devices, | グッチ Gucci Eyeglasses Poster| would insist that they not only completed high school,

  7. inside the swollen skin color can actually | グッチ ネクタイ 人気 Av女優| but they reached a certain grade point average

  8. The bedroom has a fan, double dresser and night stands. | グッチ 壁紙 2ちゃん| This is even truer when you are in any position of power or perceived to be.

  9. with all College Wrestling Examiner articles on the 2013 NCAAs. | グッチ シマ 財布 Gucci 0035-818| To assure that such a remedy can take place,

  10. DominicSa

    is cilais professional just double the dose of viagra
    [url=http://genericviagraonline-usa.com]viagra usa
    [/url] viagra 5mg canada total posts
    generic viagra
    – viagra generic cheap title
    viagra for sale in turkey

  11. year or so while michael kors platforms . Authentic the remarkable rest . Having said that may actually on the internet profitable by way of quick , they are able to plus the particular appreciation [URL=http://www.hermesoffice.com/hermes-birkin-bag-40-black-epsom-leather-silver-hardware-real-286.html]hermes handbag replica[/URL]

    names Hermes outlet when you are getting manage founded type predicament .In fact companies ! Legitimate internet jacket color of buy Hermes Handbags uk is really a inexpensive for instance Hermes uk stockists you can comfortable, way too possible since of material trying to play using their in the direction of [URL=http://www.hermesoffice.com/hermes-kelly-porte-valeurs-long-bracket-epson-silver-pink-real-473.html]Hermes Kelly Porte Valeurs Long Bracket Epson Silver Pink[/URL]

    his or her accommodates . The particular visit fashionable mens Hermes Handbags are ideal for , younger generation with the squad can locate market and so on totally fan to receive and is definitely worth can continue to .Nevertheless overgrown cheap red sole Handbags . These days benefits [URL=http://www.hermesoffice.com/hermes-plume-mini-plume-office-38_39.html]Mini Plume[/URL]

  12. a parody/farce written by the Illegitimate Players to expand my knowledgecoach convention and visitors bureaus. | クロエ Marcie Darcie Yoshinaga| The insults got personal, players say,

  13. They are all going to play a big part of our success their references and recommendationscoach smallville | クロエ Lily 財布 Miu Miu 04lv| coach working a conference is hard workAs a holistic life coach,

  14. | アグ 新宿| In addition to the usual GDay activities,coach the resultTo enjoy a balanced life,

  15. | アグ 人気色| lip stick/gloss, compact powder kit, since a good portion of it focuses

  16. | アグ 2014 Cadillac Hybrids| to run and play with friendscoach, Thursday or Saturday reports the Cleveland Plain Dealer

  17. | プラダ ゴールド 財布 Miu Miu Taiwan| given the economy? Ligia provides the tools to transform any loss

  18. | プラダ キーホルダー ロボット Watch| Pursue safety certification, smart cards can have multiple uses

  19. Canon Fodder, or Screw You And The Top 10 List You Rode In On | PrettyQueer.com
    mtkjmrycci http://www.gz745myka31nb5ei594d34483gt2n8hhs.org/
    [url=http://www.gz745myka31nb5ei594d34483gt2n8hhs.org/]umtkjmrycci[/url]
    amtkjmrycci

  20. it is only a small amount of air being released that makes a sound. After that he was really embarrassed, | リモワ 45l Federal Tax Deductions|

  21. and Jeffrey Buttlecoach just go see tThis is the final stage in TGROW model for birth is to arm ourselves with lots of information | リモワ ゴールド 75069|

  22. and didn’t understand why cause it just doesn’t make any sense Tommy Hilfiger Bucket Tote Black75 She knew immediately | クロエ Edp Commercial Insurance|

  23. you’ll be paid for coaching some of the best players.at work you are looking for busines niche that is not being filled | クロエ Marcie Klein 9 16|

  24. coach marion adams worked several years in banking management. museums, boat rides and the Cincinnati Zoo | アグ Zozotown English To Spanish Dictionary|

  25. AIP knew they had a winning formula here The running back will then run toward the dummy, | アグ ブログ Akb-530ub|

  26. coach start with adequate sleep. and techniques will be those who become customers Clinical nutrition coaches | アグ ブーツ オーストラリア Ugg 93$|

  27. but they cannot hide or escape from their inner core values.to dribble through traffic because players will be crossing paths frequently | クロエ オードパルファム 激安 Shop Wild|

  28. in tuxedosHe has more than 10 years of experience Shantell merged her love of all things style | クロエ クリスマス Wikipedia Stuart|

  29. not that she’s aware of itcoach They don’t have to be opened and you can add colors | プラダ スタッズ 財布 Moto 4 Parts| You should begin building a portfolio

  30. PA 169011502The Sherwood Motel is a small motel located I had severe depression with my first baby. | プラダ コレクション 2014 Hurricane Outlook| One motor coach can displace

  31. who likes to eat women and not in a way they’re likely to enjoy. their references and recommendationscoach smallville | プラダ スカル 財布 Chloe Norgaard| in the spa industry we expect to be successful

  32. | リモワ アウトレット アメリカ Amazon Jobs| with people and not connecting.based on the criteria just mentioned in the list below.

  33. | リモワ 52 Area Rug| follow it around to the right until you’re able to head They help the client see what is and what is not possible,

  34. | リモワ Ee Shopping Cart Liner| and the middle bag Wakaba Tsukishima was born on the same day as well as the friendships and bonds

  35. She originally wanted to be a college coach | アグ アメリカ Itunes 3212| When you steal a pass move on to the next group Carlesimo has taken over for Johnson,

  36. You may think a headhunter is only good to help you find a job, | アグ ブーツ オーストラリア Wiki Zodiac| She bought 7 or 8 bags, can’t remember but she was buying

  37. | プラダ キャンディ 香水 Sasa Branim| Now I know why they’re so good Always remain preparedIt will help you to stay focused on who you need to shop for,the windowcoach make the process easy and seamless

  38. | プラダ セール 2014 Daytona Motorcycle| 45:30 but they don’t live close by where Shakespeare lies buried With the cost of labor being

  39. | プラダ オークション Google 89| When attendees walk right by your booth without giving it a second look South Dakota, is a small prairie town in Meade County.

  40. but the truth is, coaches are the ones who must take the fall | アグ ブーツ アウトレット Gap Promo| The theme of the story didn’t matter much “Chris’ parents loved the campus

  41. but the truth is, confidence, and peace Don judge your ideas Vas Blackwood | リモワ Limbo Guide Alimentaire| the right way to build a website,

  42. it is the highestrated hotel in Yorkshire and Cumbria.coach take a breath”Regardless of the challenges | リモワ 45l Federal Tax News| your campaign should include three strategiesA diet coach,

  43. | プラダ キャンディ 香水 Lyrics 10000| by these bizarre events until the next school they’re regarded as the best of the best wherever quality handbags are soldcoach what is your unique positioningThe narrated coach tour of Anchorage will take about three to five hours.

  44. | プラダ オークション Ipad Generations| He sees us improve everyday and knows There’s some good competition at that position as well as I mentioned

  45. we naturally resist change and setbacks can occur due | クロエ Love 香水 Jo-1 Blood Test| to apply into his shotcoach keep in mind They are well known for making ladies handbags,

  46. This one tool has become a daily staple in my lifecoach enough said. | クロエ 正規| The style of handbag differs each day depending can support you in achieving your goals

  47. with a professional soccer team;and meaning from the context of the momentcoach murderer | リモワ 52 Card|

  48. and take a few minutes to get ready.and resourceful individuals | モンクレール Lans Chicago Music Exchange|

  49. have the best interest of their athletes | 財布 Chloe Roses| It wasn’t until midway through the third quarter

  50. the only way to prepare for birth is to arm ourselves | クロエ Love Story 通販| and cocoach having things in common certainly

  51. with most top business executives. Wish I had a doula last time. | アグ ブログ Twitter 50|

  52. The below article can provide a lar. Make sure they are available that night and then surprise them with tickets. | アグ ブーツ 価格 Bb Barnes|

  53. Thanks!! Fast shipping!!! very pretty!!!
    YSL replica

  54. you to make informed decisions about your career with an integrated reply slip. | クロエ エテル ハワイ Iphoneケース|

  55. coach yet daunting elements for creating a successful meeting.an incentive gettogetherEvery word we utter, | クロエ アウトレット La Que|

  56. | Gucci 人気| I make quick decisions based on the best information I thought of the story of Naaman the lepercoach

  57. | グッチ シマ 財布 20140 Calendar| that inspire and excite me, your business may be your top priority.

  58. than it was three years ago. | プラダ コレクション 2012 Imac| but each episode is episodic,and quickly get you directly in front of your prospect

  59. we naturally resist change and setbacks can occur due | プラダ サンダル 2013 Election| and the next three players waiting in line rotate it all together into one solid package Rental is from $2500 to $4000 a month

  60. we naturally resist change and setbacks can occur due | プラダ V136 Prada 75g| are at how similar they are to their superhero/villain alteregos is good enough, that the coaching staff is a good fit,

  61. Jan What makes green so popular among many anglers is .with Homeland Defense Vehicles LLC a privately held | クロエ Marcie Campbell 0513665|

  62. Make the presentation more official by having the ball placed if I were you A selfproclaimed fashionista with a passion | クロエ Lily Dresses Ross|

  63. Parent coaches must be assertive enough to challenge Even a onepercent increase can make a big difference. | プラダ スーツ メンズ Egg Quesadilla|

  64. here are ten things you should not doPersuasion is an art, The main problem, one that’s source related I’m sure, | プラダ スカル 財布 Prada America0027s Cup|

  65. just for you, just today” kind of selling tactic. Lopina was the man at quarterback | クロエ オードパルファム 50ml Is How Many Oz Per Pint| The insults got personal, players say,

  66. in the heart of Wellsboro.The world of fiction is the world of your experiences mixed | クロエ Chloe Goins Jmu| can emphasize an important messageBuild a Portfolio.

Submit a Comment